Chefman Digital Air Fryer VS Best Choice Products Air Fryer The Ultimate Budget Air Fryer Showdown
Our Testing Methodology: A True Side-by-Side Battle
To declare a true winner, we conducted a rigorous, simultaneous, side-by-side comparison. We purchased both the Chefman TurboFry Touch 8-Quart Air Fryer and the Best Choice Products 10-in-1 7.4-Quart XL Air Fryer. We cooked identical foods, in identical quantities, at the same time, for every single test. This review is based on direct, empirical data from our test kitchen, evaluating everything from cooking performance and speed to ease of use and cleaning.
In the fiercely competitive world of kitchen appliances, the battle for the budget-conscious consumer is where the real action is. Two brands that consistently rise to the top of the “best value” lists are Chefman and Best Choice Products. Both have built a reputation for offering feature-rich, large-capacity air fryers at prices that make the premium brands blush. They promise to deliver that coveted crispy, air-fried goodness without emptying your wallet.
But when you’re faced with two seemingly similar options on Amazon, a tough question arises: which one is truly the better buy? Do they perform the same? Is one easier to use? Is one built to last longer? We decided to end the debate. We’re putting two of their most popular large-capacity models into the ring for a head-to-head, no-holds-barred showdown. In this corner, the sleek and popular Chefman. And in the other, the feature-packed challenger from Best Choice Products. Let the battle for the title of “Best Budget Air Fryer” begin!
Meet The Contenders
To make this a fair fight, we selected two closely matched, large-capacity digital models from each brand. Let’s get to know our fighters.
Chefman TurboFry Touch 8-Quart
The Chefman TurboFry Touch is known for its massive 8-quart capacity, simple digital interface, and a flat, square basket that maximizes cooking surface area. It’s a minimalist powerhouse focused on doing one thing well: air frying large batches of food.
- Claim to Fame: Huge capacity, ease of use.
- Target Audience: Large families, meal preppers.
Best Choice Products 10-in-1 XL 7.4-Quart
The Best Choice Products (BCP) model comes out swinging with a feature-packed approach. It boasts 10 one-touch cooking presets, a slightly smaller but still massive 7.4-quart capacity, and a comprehensive accessory kit including a pizza pan and roasting rack.
- Claim to Fame: Versatility, included accessories.
- Target Audience: Cooks who want an all-in-one solution.
Tale Of The Tape: Feature-By-Feature Showdown
Before we start cooking, let’s break down how these two contenders stack up on paper. The spec sheet reveals some key differences in their design philosophies.
| Feature | Chefman TurboFry Touch | Best Choice Products 10-in-1 |
|---|---|---|
| Capacity | 8 Quarts | 7.4 Quarts |
| Wattage | 1700 Watts | 1700 Watts |
| Temperature Range | 200°F – 450°F | 160°F – 400°F |
| Basket Shape | Square, Flat Bottom | Slightly Rounded, with Crisper Tray |
| Presets | 4 (Fries, Chicken, Fish, Meat) | 10 (incl. Pizza, Bake, Dehydrate) |
| Interface | Top-mounted Touchscreen | Front-facing Touchscreen |
| Accessories | None included | Pizza Pan, Roasting Rack, Tongs |
| Special Feature | High Max Temperature | Versatility and Accessories |
Initial Analysis: Right away, we see a clash of styles. The Chefman is a specialist, boasting a slightly larger capacity and a higher maximum temperature, ideal for searing. The BCP is a generalist, offering far more presets and a useful accessory kit, making it more of a multi-cooker. The fight is on!
The Ultimate Cooking Gauntlet: Side-by-Side Performance
This is the heart of our comparison. We cooked four different foods side-by-side to see which machine delivered the best results. Each round has a winner.
Round 1: The French Fry Face-Off
We placed 1.5 lbs of identical frozen shoestring fries in each basket and set both machines to 400°F. The Chefman’s “Fries” preset defaulted to 15 minutes, while the BCP’s was 20 minutes. We cooked both for 18 minutes, shaking halfway, to keep it fair.
Chefman Results
The Chefman produced very evenly cooked fries. The color was a consistent golden-brown across the entire batch. The texture was excellent—crispy on the outside, fluffy on the inside. The flat, square basket allowed the fries to spread out nicely, which contributed to the even cooking.
Best Choice Products Results
The BCP fries were also very crispy, perhaps even slightly crispier in spots than the Chefman’s. However, the cooking was less even. We found a few fries on the bottom that were lighter in color, while some on top were a deeper brown. The slightly deeper, rounder basket seemed to concentrate the heat more on the top layer.
ROUND 1 WINNER: CHEFMAN (for evenness)
Round 2: The Chicken Wing War
We cooked 2 lbs of fresh, dry-rubbed chicken wings in each machine at 400°F for 25 minutes, flipping them halfway through.
Chefman Results
The Chefman did a fantastic job. The skin was rendered beautifully and became uniformly crispy and golden. The meat remained juicy. Its large surface area allowed the wings to cook without steaming, which is key for crispy skin. It produced a picture-perfect batch of wings.
Best Choice Products Results
The BCP also produced crispy, delicious wings. The skin had a slightly harder, crunchier crisp in spots, which some of our testers preferred. It rendered the fat very effectively. Similar to the fries, the results were slightly less uniform than the Chefman, but the high points of crispiness were excellent.
ROUND 2 WINNER: DRAW
Round 3: The Salmon Showdown
We cooked two identical 6-ounce salmon fillets, skin-on, at 400°F for 8 minutes.
Chefman Results
Using its higher 450°F max temp for the last minute, the Chefman produced a beautiful sear on top of the salmon, while the inside was perfectly flaky and moist. The skin on the bottom was rendered and slightly crisp. It was a restaurant-quality result.
Best Choice Products Results
The BCP, limited to 400°F, cooked the salmon perfectly as well. The inside was moist and flaky, and the skin was cooked through. However, it lacked the beautiful browned crust that the Chefman was able to achieve. It was a perfectly good piece of salmon, just less visually and texturally exciting.
ROUND 3 WINNER: CHEFMAN (for its high-heat advantage)
Design & Usability Battle
In terms of build quality, both units feel appropriate for their price point—primarily plastic construction with sturdy baskets. The Chefman’s top-mounted display is sleek but can be harder to see if the unit is placed under a cabinet. The BCP’s front-facing display is bright, clear, and easier to read at a glance. We also found the BCP’s wider array of presets to be more useful for beginners who don’t want to guess cook times. For pure ease of use, the BCP gets a slight edge.
The Cleaning Challenge
After cooking the chicken wings, we put both baskets to the cleaning test. The Chefman’s flat, one-piece basket was incredibly easy to clean. There were no complex parts or crevices for grease to hide. The BCP’s basket requires you to remove a separate crisper tray from the bottom, which is an extra step and creates more corners to clean. Both are dishwasher safe, but for handwashing, the Chefman’s simpler design was noticeably faster to clean.
A Note on Safety and Handling
Both of these large baskets can be heavy and are dangerously hot after cooking. To safely shake or remove the baskets, especially when they’re full, we strongly recommend using a pair of fryer gloves for a secure grip and excellent heat protection.
And The Winner Is…
After a grueling series of tests, it’s time to declare a winner. Both air fryers performed admirably and represent incredible value. They both cook food to a delicious, crispy finish. But in a head-to-head battle, there can be only one champion. While some users may prefer a different style of appliance entirely, like a large air fryer oven such as the Kalorik MAXX, for this basket-style showdown, the verdict is in.
THE ULTIMATE BUDGET CHAMPION IS…
This was an incredibly close fight, but the Chefman wins by a narrow decision. While the Best Choice Products air fryer offers more features and accessories, the Chefman excels at the core function of an air fryer: cooking food with superior evenness. Its simpler design is a strength, leading to more consistent results and easier cleaning. Its higher maximum temperature is a tangible advantage for searing. If your primary goal is to get the best possible air-fried results for large quantities of food, the Chefman’s focus on performance gives it the edge.
However, this doesn’t mean the Best Choice Products air fryer isn’t a fantastic option. If you value versatility and want an appliance that can also bake a small pizza or roast on a rack right out of the box, the BCP is an incredible value and may be the better choice for you. For other great options, be sure to check out our complete guide to the best digital air fryers on the market.
